

Nobody's Perfect
What happens when a single-parent-dad needs extra cash and disguises himself to win a $50,000 contest – only to fall head over heels for the lady judge?
With meddling family, outrageous misunderstandings, a love story hanging by a thread, this fast-paced comedy is packed with big laughs and an unforgettable finale. You won’t want to miss the feel-good, laugh-out-loud hit!
NOV 19, 2025 - FEB 1ST, 2026
For Groups of 8 or more: Seating is available, Call Now!
Meet the Hilarious Cast of Nobody's Perfect
Jim O'Heir

Jim O’Heir* (Leonard Loftus) While mostly recognized for playing the office punching bag on PARKS AND RECREATION, Emmy winner O’Heir has graced the small screen on a regular basis for the last 30 years. Partial credits include; BETTER CALL SAUL, BROOKLYN NINE-NINE, 911, BOSTON LEGAL, FRIENDS, CRIMINAL MINDS, ALLY MCBEAL, DIAGNOSIS MURDER, MALCOLM IN THE MIDDLE, STAR TREK VOYAGER, JUST SHOOT ME, and countless other critically acclaimed shows. Jim can also be seen in a number of feature films. He worked with Stephen Soderbergh on LUCKY LOGAN. He has played alongside Steve Carell and Keira Knightley in Focus Features’ SEEKING A FRIEND FOR THE END OF THE WORLD as well as starring in Ned Crowley’s feature film MIDDLE MAN which won the Grand Jury Prize for New American Cinema at the Seattle International Film Festival. He can be seen with fellow PARKS costar Nick Offerman in BAD TIMES AT THE EL ROYALE. As for life off screen, O’Heir stays busy with a mix of activities including; boating, travel, poker, and seizing as many opportunities as possible to cross paths with old Hollywood greats. Jim began his career in theater and has loved working with the amazing talent, on stage and off, at the New Theatre. He is also a self-proclaimed pet lover and supports various organizations that work to protect the well-being of animals. You might not want to carpool with Jim, as he is very open about his appreciation for Barry Manilow and the occasional Broadway show tune.
KyLee Hennes

KyLee Hennes* (Dee Dee Loftus) is overjoyed to be making her New Theatre debut! The Wisconsin native holds a Bachelor of Architecture from IIT in Chicago and merges her love of theatre and architecture as an associate scenic designer in Milwaukee and NYC. Recent associate credits include MR PUPPY THE MUSICAL (Off-Broadway), DIDO & AENEAS (Opera Lafayette, DC), and MURDER GIRL (Milwaukee Chamber Theatre). Performing since the age of 8, she was a finalist in the search for DOLLY: AN ORIGINAL MUSICAL. Select acting credits: THE SOUND OF MUSIC, DIE ZAUBERFLÖTE (Lyric Opera of Chicago), VIOLET, ANNIE (Skylight Music Theatre), EVERYBODY (Milwaukee Rep). Endless appreciation to her team; KGM Vocal Studio, Serendipity Entertainment, and Stewart Talent Chicago.
Kelly Felthous

Kelly Felthous* (Harriet Copeland) is thrilled be back at New Theatre after playing Elizabeth in CATCH ME. Favorite credits include: Gloria in BOEING BOEING, Violet in VIOLET, Roxy in CHICAGO, Sally Bowles in CABARET, Audrey in LITTLE SHOP OF HORRORS, Lauren in KINKY BOOTS, and Dawn in WAITRESS. She originated the roles of Caroline in TRIP OF LOVE, Ruby in MAX AND RUBY, Eva in BRING IT ON, and Gloria in FLASHDANCE. National Tours: Marty in GREASE and Galinda/Nessarose u/s in WICKED. Kelly has also appeared on LAW AND ORDER SVU, NIGHT SKY, and numerous commercials. NYU/CAP21 grad and proud AEA/SAG member. Follow @KellyFelthous or check out KellyFelthous.com for more info!
Victor Raider-Wexler

Victor Raider-Wexler* (Gus) is marking his sixth appearance at NTR, most recently, CATCH ME with Jim O'Heir. He is a member of Kansas City Actors Theatre and appeared this year in GRAND HORIZONS. His thirty-year career in New York included Broadway stints with GYPSY starring Tyne Daley and in August Wilson's MA RAINEY'S BLACK BOTTOM, plus off-Broadway including THE BOYS NEXT DOOR and THE PASSION OF DRACULA. His fifteen years in Hollywood gathered recurring roles in SEINFELD, EVERYBODY LOVES RAYMOND, and THE KING OF QUEENS, among others. He worked with Netflix as Frederick Esty in BOSS BABY and Vendel in Guillermo del Torro’s TROLL HUNTERS.


Elvis & Elton
"The CONCERT that
SHOULD HAVE BEEN."
Starring Victor Trevino Jr., Graceland's Ultimate Elvis Tribute Artist and introducing international performance artist, Sean McGibbon as Elton.
When a mother in London brought home an early recording of Elvis to her son, it was this music that inspired Reginald Dwight to become Elton John. Now the two legends join in a celebration concert of each other, and the music that has inspired millions.
FEB 5TH, 2026 - APR 19TH, 2026\
For Groups of 8 or more: Seating is available, Call Now!
Meet the Amazing Cast of Elvis & Elton
Victor Trevino Jr.

Victor Trevino Jr.* (Elvis Presley) Victor Trevino Jr. is an internationally acclaimed, award-winning Elvis Presley Tribute Artist, celebrated for his authentic performances and electrifying stage presence. A lifelong fan of the King of Rock ‘n’ Roll, Victor specializes in Elvis’ early rockabilly era of the 1950s, as well as his movie years in the 1960s—capturing the raw energy, charisma, and youthful spirit that made Elvis a global phenomenon.
Victor has been performing professionally since 2005 and continues to mesmerize audiences across the U.S. and around the world. His uncanny ability to channel Elvis’ voice, look, and moves—while using his own natural vocals—has earned him a devoted global fanbase and high praise from critics and Elvis Presley Enterprises (EPE).
Sean McGibbon

Sean McGibbon* (Elton John) is an Austin, Texas native with a huge case of ADHD, and a variety theatre background. Outside of performing, Sean is an accomplished juggler, magician, chess player and tap dancer, and loves everything Golden Age musical theatre. His influences include Sammy Davis Jr, Gene Kelly, Donald O'Connor and of course... The Killer! Credits include: North Shore Music Theater's SINGING IN THE RAIN (Cosmo Brown), 1st National Tour MILLION DOLLAR QUARTET (Jerry Lee Lewis), 25th Anniversary National Tour THE BUDDY HOLLY STORY, Encores ON YOUR TOES (Dir. Warren Carlyle), and Goodspeed's THE GREAT AMERICAN MOUSICAL (Dir. Julie Andrews). 2012 BFA Musical Theater/Psychology Minor/Jazz Minor Texas State University.







